Roger Moss, author of Victorian Exterior Decoration and many other books researched historic paint colors used by period for various styles of architecture.
Actual historic colors from historic brochures were assigned Munsell color codes.
These color codes were then re-created in the Sherwin Williams Historic Color Pallet in the 1980’s.
Unfortunately since then many of the colors were changed or discontinued. All colors can be mixed but color swatches are not available for all colors.
I have discovered that the Roger Moss colors here are now “modified” versions of actual historic paint colors used. There are colors from Benjamin Moore, Behr, and other manufacturers that are more authentic matches for certain colors. Although possibly not as appealing, you should have the option to choose colors that are as accurate as possible if historic authenticity is what you want.
If the colors you chose for your house come from the Roger Moss color chart and you would like to see what an more authentic color replacement would be, the replacement color is listed below.
Below is a chart sorted in order by Sherwin Williams color numbers with the color name next to it. Find the color you are searching for by SW color number. If it is not listed then there is no replacement color.
For those listed below there is a number showing the difference the recommended color is from the Munsell color. The Sherwin Williams colors in the left column have a greater difference than those replacement colors. This means that these colors are NOT a perfect match to the Munsell color but are still a better match than the Sherwin Williams color we are replacing.
Abbreviations below are: bm=Benjamin Moore, sw=Sherwin Williams
|Sherwin Williams #||SW Color Name||Replacement Color Name||Replacement #||Munsell difference|
|0030||Colonial Yellow||bm york harbor yellow||2154-40||2.5|
|0043||Peristyle Brass||bm everard gold||cw 435||2.3|
|0067||Belvedere Cream||sw peace yellow||2857||2|
|2803||Rookwood Terra Cotta Trim||sw red cent||6341||1.4|
|2804||Renwick Rose Beige||bm colorado clay||ac-15||2.1|
|2805||Renwick Beige||bm hint of mauve||2097-50||0.8|
|2806||Rookwood Brown||bm penny||2163-30||1.8|
|2807||Rookwood Medium Brown Trim||bm satchel||AF-240||2.6|
|2808||Rookwood Dark Brown Trim||behr death by chocolate||MQ1-54||2.5|
|2809||Rookwood Shutter Green||essex green||2.9|
|2810||Rookwood Sash Green||behr blue fir||s430-7d||1.6|
|2811||Rookwood Blue Green||bm caribbean teal||2123-20||1.2|
|2812||Rookwood Jade||sw jade dragon||9129||1.9|
|2813||Downing Straw||bm twilight gold||1069||1.4|
|2814||Rookwood Antique Gold||behr syrup||MQ2-02||1.4|
|2815||Renwick Olive||bm raccoon hollow||978||1.4|
|2816||Rookwood Dark Green||behr fig tree||MQ6-58||2.3|
|2817||Rookwood Amber Trim||bm golden harvest||2157-20||2.4|
|2819||Downing Slate Trim||bm Lead gray||2131-30||1.2|
|2820||Downing Earth||sw tiki hut||7509||0.8|
|2821||Downing Stone||bm storm cloud gray||2140-40||1|
|2822||Downing Sand||Behr Suede Beige||MQ3-38|
|2823||Rookwood Clay||valspar lone log||327a-4||1.5|
|2824||Renwick Golden Oak||sw caramelo||9106||1.7|
|2829||Classical White||bm royal silk||939|
|2832||Colonial Revival Gray||bm gull wing gray||2134-50||1.2|
|6386||Napery||bm peach melba||78||0.5|
|6397||Nankeen||behr indian spice||M300-6D||2.3|
|6424||Tansey Green||bm frasier fur||503||3|
|6696||Quilt Gold||Gold Leaf||BM 201||1.6|
|7608||Adrift||sw bluesy note||9064||1.7|
|9014||Pollen Powder||bm broadway lights||298||1.5|
|9107||Uber Umber||valspar Sepia||323-6|