Almost 99 percent of window shutters on homes are wrong resulting in very bad curb appeal. See if your shutters are bad and learn what to do right to make your home look its best.
Try Our Old House Guy Virtual House Painting Service. See a photo of your house in numerous historic paint colors.
Need to add a section about aligning false permanent exterior non-hinged shutters that do not exactly match the window height.
Also, slats up vs slats down.
Read on – it’s there.
Hello. We have a home in a historical district with old wooden one inch shutters.
They are not energy efficient and we want to know if we should buy 2.5 inch wooden shutters or faux 2.5 inch wooden shutters ? We had wood on our last home and they were great but very expensive and you can’t tell them apart unless up very close or touch one. What would you buy ? Will the historical district organization ever tell me which to buy as long it keeps the basic historical look 1928 ? Please reply as I respect your opinion. Best Regards
Hi Johnny
Shutters help conserve energy if they are working shutters and are closed during the winter. The louvers must also be closed tightly. For a 1928 house I would recommend a shutter with a cut-out. They can be half paneled or louvered but should have a cut-out. Your HPC probably doesn’t have a clue – unfortunately.
You did a color job layout for us earlier this year. We are now in the process of choosing wooden shutters to replace the fake aluminum shutters that were nailed to the house in 1953. Our home was built in 1865 and we now have approval by the Historical Architectural Review Board to restore the original porch with the removal of the asbestos tiling and new wood shutter along with restoring the corbels. Based on your blog, it appears that the louvered shutters shown in the 1927 picture we sent may have been a later addition., What would you suggest as the appropriate types of shutters for our first and second floors. And would there have been shutters on the third floor stained glass window area?
Hi Joanne – For me to check out your house I would need you to reply to one of my emails with the project number in the subject line. However for an 1865 house you should have operable louvered shutters. No shutters on stained glass windows though.
This is a great educational piece. I also have a ranch with a long southern front porch. It has Centered door, 2 sets of sash windows on each side and shutters would certainly add character. It is not a historical house, but it actually looks like it needs something. I am assuming panel shutters would be a safe bet, or louvered because it is in the south. But I do love board and batten for the rustic appearance. Do you think it matters?
Thank you,
Amy
Hi – for a ranch house any style shutter would work.
I’d like to repaint my shutters, but I’m not sure what color to pick. We have a one story ranch with tan vinyl siding and a grey roof. I’m thinking black for the shutter colors. Do you think that’s a good idea?
Keith of https://www.moversfortwayne.com
You can’t go wrong with black.
I just bought a little log cabin. It’s about 700 square feet. It is brown and I was wondering what color shutters I should put on the cabin, the cabin was built in 1940.
Board and batten and paint them benjamin moore essex green.
Already have the exterior louvered shutters on each side of entrance door on a townhouse which are the original close to 35 years. Want to add louvered shutters to a double window same front entrance. Would it really matter if the slats are slightly a different size (smaller). Color is “bronze” that looks like a deep color grey.
Please give me advise
It would be better if you emailed me with a photo. I would say they should be the same size.
I have a two story colonial that we are in the process of residing. The top floor is siding in a dark grey and the lower level is white painted brick. There are 4 sets of 2 windows upstairs and downstairs there are two sets of long windows (livingroom/diningroom). The windows are all trimmed in white. I thought that I wanted shutters on all the front windows but now I am thinking of only putting them on the first floor, against the white painted brick.
I would like your thoughts of putting shutters on all, or just first floor. I don’t recall seeing shutters on one level only, especially a traditional colonial with a straight front.
This is a question that should be emailed to me with a photo. I would shutter all windows.
I am in the midst of stripping and painting my shutters. Along with that I am planning on painting the window sashes. I would like to go with a red for both of these but am having a hard time finding the correct red color. Most seem to bright red and the first attempt doesn’t look great. Is there a red color that is traditional. Our house is a colonial revival built in the 1920s. Last question is what paint sheen is appropriate for shutters?
Hi Joe
Use gloss paint for shutters. As for red try Benjamin Moore Classic Burgundy or Sherwin Williams Rookwood Red which has a bit of brown in it.
Our house is over 100 years old. The first floor on the front of the house has the original shutters. Would it look right if be put new vinyl where they are missing?
If you can’t do it right don’t do it at all.
Hello, I have a newly remodeled Craftsman-style house with large casement windows. The frame of the windows (and inside of the flat casing) is 58.5” tall by 31.5” wide. I intend to install single framed board and batten shutters next to each of the windows. How large should the shutters be? I assume they should overlap the casing opening but not sure by how much. Also, it’s not a historic house—should I use hinges to install them or just screw them in place. Thanks much for the advice.
Hi – first of all you shouldn’t have shutters on casement windows. This is mostly because in the US the windows open outwards so how would you be able to close the shutters? Not that you are going to ever close your shutters but really you shouldn’t use them. In Europe the windows open inward so they can use shutters.
A double hung window has what is called a blind stop around the perimeter of the window. (refer to diagram on this page to see blind stop https://www.oldhouseguy.com/window-designs/) Storm windows and shutters both fit into the casing and rest on this blind stop. The shutters then fill the entire area inside the window casing. To measure you would measure the area from the inside of one side of the casing to the other.
Casement windows do not have a blind stop but the area would still be between the casing. Additionally you need to use hinges for the right look otherwise they will just look flat. I still do not recommend shutters for your house though.